I gave it 4.5 cuz there's not enough boobage >:(
Kidding, of course. But the real reason I gave it a 4.5 is for a few reasons.
Pros: It's got a fun storyline, fun quests, most dungeons are unique(excluding mystery), you get to pick good or evil(though I wish it wasn't so cut-&-dry so-to-speak) and i like that you can actually craft things(something often overlooked in games of this type)
Cons:The art, effects, and animations could have been better(they seem a tad lazy), character creation was lacking Ex: not enough color choices(RGB sliders = good plan. Though kudos for actually having creation at all), and lastly, I don't like that you made it so shops would sell under item value. In no universe would a merchant do that. Better plan would be to have the buy price stop at 100, then have the sell price increase by 2 each time after buying maxes, until sell is at 99. Makes it more realistic.