I'm Not Sure

The first thing I noticed about the piece was that the Bass was too loud. The loudest instrument of a song should be the Melody, then the Bass, then the Drums, then the harmonies, etc.

The melody was very accurate, which I personally prefer in a Remix. If you can keep what's familiar and switch it up without writing a new song, you've got a good remix.

Saying that, the concept was good too. I didn't feel like you were grasping for an idea; you knew what you had set out to compose.

Unfortunately, originality takes a blow on this one. I see in your summary that you were going for the "NES" feel. But I feel like this piece didn't have anything to discern it from the original Nintendo song.

Here's my score:
Instrument Blend--- 0/1
Accuracy--------------- 1/1
Clear Concept ------- 2/2
Originality------------- 0/2
Appeal----------------- 2/4

Total------------------- 5/10

Other Comments - I weigh my own personal appeals heavily when I review. I had to take off points for originality and appeal, because this wasn't my style. But don't be discouraged! The piece was well put together.

sounds like its from zelda

it sounds like it's from Zelda