NaN:NaN
NaN:NaN
--:-- / --:--
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

refcherry just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Stop with souls like games

617 Views | 13 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

They are awful. The only reason darksouls was hard is because of the janky controls, lack of direction, and general heaviness of the game. Slow moving animations and heavy armor with stupid mechanics doesn’t make a game hard so stop making games imitating this. Tired of the same 3 games being made… Darksouls copies, battle royales, and mobas. Make a unique game. Rant over.

Response to Stop with souls like games Aug 27, 2021


I get it. I don't think people should stop developing Dark Souls-style games,

but the "Souls-like" label has definitely been milked out and perhaps even abused by now xD

Response to Stop with souls like games Aug 27, 2021


I never really cared for the Souls-style of games (with a few exceptions) if mostly because they find ways to make it either obnoxiously difficult or have combat be so sluggish and plodding, it’s hardly satisfying. I could tolerate the Dark Souls series, but even they had plenty of kinks to iron out in between games, something that most other Soulsbourne clones just ignored, even with FromSoftware themselves.


Just stop worrying, and love the bomb.

BBS Signature

Response to Stop with souls like games Aug 29, 2021


I love action RPGs that aren't even that good to begin with mmmm


BBS Signature

Response to Stop with souls like games Aug 29, 2021


At 8/29/21 03:22 AM, animemademegay wrote:I love action RPGs that aren't even that good to begin with mmmm


I love any game that’s not trying to copy crap games lol

Response to Stop with souls like games Aug 29, 2021


At 8/29/21 03:26 AM, ShayInator wrote:
At 8/29/21 03:22 AM, animemademegay wrote:I love action RPGs that aren't even that good to begin with mmmm

I love any game that’s not trying to copy crap games lol


mmmm my favorite attack then roll type game


BBS Signature

Response to Stop with souls like games Aug 29, 2021


I agree..

Response to Stop with souls like games Sep 4, 2021


not to mention theyre all ugly as hell, too. im so sick of fantasy MMO games with moldy, washed out colors and fire so bright it makes your eyes bleed. if youre going to make ANY game at all, at least make it so the player can actually tell what they're looking at without having to turn their brightness all the way up!

Response to Stop with souls like games Sep 4, 2021


At 9/4/21 02:35 PM, Jibber-Jabber wrote:not to mention theyre all ugly as hell, too. im so sick of fantasy MMO games with moldy, washed out colors and fire so bright it makes your eyes bleed. if youre going to make ANY game at all, at least make it so the player can actually tell what they're looking at without having to turn their brightness all the way up!


I agree! Everything is just a shade of grey honestly lol

Response to Stop with souls like games Sep 8, 2021


At 8/27/21 03:29 AM, ShayInator wrote:They are awful. The only reason darksouls was hard is because of the janky controls, lack of direction, and general heaviness of the game. Slow moving animations and heavy armor with stupid mechanics doesn’t make a game hard so stop making games imitating this. Tired of the same 3 games being made… Darksouls copies, battle royales, and mobas. Make a unique game. Rant over.


Have you tried...


Getting Gud?


От каждого по способностям, каждому по потребностям

BBS Signature

Response to Stop with souls like games Sep 9, 2021


At 9/8/21 06:28 AM, 0N1MU5HA wrote:
At 8/27/21 03:29 AM, ShayInator wrote:They are awful. The only reason darksouls was hard is because of the janky controls, lack of direction, and general heaviness of the game. Slow moving animations and heavy armor with stupid mechanics doesn’t make a game hard so stop making games imitating this. Tired of the same 3 games being made… Darksouls copies, battle royales, and mobas. Make a unique game. Rant over.

Have you tried...

Getting Gud?


Dodge roll, hit, dodge roll, hit, heal, dodge roll. No getting good, just takes a lot of time. Why am I paying to not have fun?!

Response to Stop with souls like games Sep 9, 2021


At 9/9/21 05:09 AM, ShayInator wrote:
At 9/8/21 06:28 AM, 0N1MU5HA wrote:
At 8/27/21 03:29 AM, ShayInator wrote:They are awful. The only reason darksouls was hard is because of the janky controls, lack of direction, and general heaviness of the game. Slow moving animations and heavy armor with stupid mechanics doesn’t make a game hard so stop making games imitating this. Tired of the same 3 games being made… Darksouls copies, battle royales, and mobas. Make a unique game. Rant over.

Have you tried...

Getting Gud?

Dodge roll, hit, dodge roll, hit, heal, dodge roll. No getting good, just takes a lot of time. Why am I paying to not have fun?!


So your gripe lies with the combat in these games?


От каждого по способностям, каждому по потребностям

BBS Signature

Response to Stop with souls like games Sep 9, 2021


At 9/9/21 05:15 AM, 0N1MU5HA wrote:
At 9/9/21 05:09 AM, ShayInator wrote:
At 9/8/21 06:28 AM, 0N1MU5HA wrote:
At 8/27/21 03:29 AM, ShayInator wrote:They are awful. The only reason darksouls was hard is because of the janky controls, lack of direction, and general heaviness of the game. Slow moving animations and heavy armor with stupid mechanics doesn’t make a game hard so stop making games imitating this. Tired of the same 3 games being made… Darksouls copies, battle royales, and mobas. Make a unique game. Rant over.

Have you tried...

Getting Gud?

Dodge roll, hit, dodge roll, hit, heal, dodge roll. No getting good, just takes a lot of time. Why am I paying to not have fun?!

So your gripe lies with the combat in these games?


No, it lies with everything. Everything is HEAVY and CLUNKY. You cannot do anything without feeling like a bag of rocks. Mechanics are trash, the game is buggy, the game is super hard without a guide otherwise you bone yourself and are in the completely wrong area because the game doesn’t guide you in where to go ever. Just because a game is a clunky piece of junk doesn’t make it a hard game. I can play the game perfectly fine, HOWEVER the game is annoying and mistaken for hard by just being so tanky for no reason. Same goes for Monster Hunter. There’s no reason to have 13 different buttons to do one thing.

Response to Stop with souls like games Sep 9, 2021


At 9/9/21 05:24 AM, ShayInator wrote:
At 9/9/21 05:15 AM, 0N1MU5HA wrote:
At 9/9/21 05:09 AM, ShayInator wrote:
At 9/8/21 06:28 AM, 0N1MU5HA wrote:
At 8/27/21 03:29 AM, ShayInator wrote:They are awful. The only reason darksouls was hard is because of the janky controls, lack of direction, and general heaviness of the game. Slow moving animations and heavy armor with stupid mechanics doesn’t make a game hard so stop making games imitating this. Tired of the same 3 games being made… Darksouls copies, battle royales, and mobas. Make a unique game. Rant over.

Have you tried...

Getting Gud?

Dodge roll, hit, dodge roll, hit, heal, dodge roll. No getting good, just takes a lot of time. Why am I paying to not have fun?!

So your gripe lies with the combat in these games?

No, it lies with everything. Everything is HEAVY and CLUNKY. You cannot do anything without feeling like a bag of rocks. Mechanics are trash, the game is buggy, the game is super hard without a guide otherwise you bone yourself and are in the completely wrong area because the game doesn’t guide you in where to go ever. Just because a game is a clunky piece of junk doesn’t make it a hard game. I can play the game perfectly fine, HOWEVER the game is annoying and mistaken for hard by just being so tanky for no reason. Same goes for Monster Hunter. There’s no reason to have 13 different buttons to do one thing.


I mean.... the original Dark Souls... I can see some of those criticisms being valid...


I played Dark Souls III and Nioh and Bloodborne before playing the original Dark Souls.

Going from smooth and refined to an almost primitive version of a game in the same genre was definitely off-putting at first. My biggest complaint was the clunkyness of the combat. ...and I agree with you on that.


If you work at it, you will get better though.

...and if you are playing a more modern game released by From or a Soulslike, chances are... it will be nowhere near as clunky as the original Dark Souls was.


Can I ask you which games you've tried so far?



От каждого по способностям, каждому по потребностям

BBS Signature