00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme
Upgrade Your Account!

HO HO HOPE you become a Newgrounds Supporter this year!

We're working hard to give you the best site possible, but we have bills to pay and community support is vital to keep things going and growing. Thank you for considering!

Become a Supporter so NG can see another Christmas!

Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise.

145 Views | 16 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-15 05:57:35


Hey everyone. I appreciate this is probably a common thread, but I didn't want to go around necroposting.


I recently treated myself to a small Wacom with the intention of getting started making some dumb animations, I've had a look at the Animation Resources section of NG, as well as my own cursory searches and I think I've narrowed it down to either Krita or Pencil2D.


Is there any particular reason I should pick one or the other, or is there another program I should consider? Bear in mind I'm brand new (outside of stupid windows movie maker sprite animations I made when I was like, 10-11). I'd also heard blender could be used for 2D, but from what I understand it's really more for editing 3D environments.


Thanks in advance. <3


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-16 03:05:13


At 12/15/24 05:57 AM, DeaghlanNG wrote:Hey everyone. I appreciate this is probably a common thread, but I didn't want to go around necroposting.

I recently treated myself to a small Wacom with the intention of getting started making some dumb animations, I've had a look at the Animation Resources section of NG, as well as my own cursory searches and I think I've narrowed it down to either Krita or Pencil2D.

Is there any particular reason I should pick one or the other, or is there another program I should consider? Bear in mind I'm brand new (outside of stupid windows movie maker sprite animations I made when I was like, 10-11). I'd also heard blender could be used for 2D, but from what I understand it's really more for editing 3D environments.

Thanks in advance. <3


I use krita for digital drawing, but I never used it for animation, so I can't say how well it works.

Nor have I ever used Pencil2D

But what I can say is try both. They are both free, see which one you like, there is no downside to trying free programs.


I personally use Blender for 2d animation, but I've been using blender for over a decade. Thus I don't think any feedback on the Blender 2d animation from me wouldn't be unbiased XD

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-16 04:17:07


Fair enough. Thanks for the response :)


Spent yesterday messing around with Krita, I think I'm gonna stick with that for now. But I did also download blender and pencil2D, just to compare. Wasn't sure if there were any objectively better reasons to use them over another program, although I think blender may be a bit too much for me (at least right now).


I've only ever drawn on paper until now, so the tablet feels real weird at the moment LOL


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-16 04:24:12


Oh, one more thing. Seeing as you've used Krita and blender.


How does blender differ to Krita in terms of 2D? My understanding is you draw in more of a 3D space - I just wanted to start out with something more basic for now, then I can move on to something like that later.


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-16 18:57:58


I've used krita and pencil 2d a lot before. I use krita for artworks and it's pretty good. The animation tool is fine. If you're a beginner, use pencil 2d for a bit. Once you've been animating for a bit, I'd recommend using a "legally" acquired copy of flash. Flash 8 is good, though I've heard cs6 is also good.


Join the Pencil 2D Collab!

BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-16 19:06:11


At 12/16/24 06:57 PM, BlakeyTakeyTheCakey wrote:I've used krita and pencil 2d a lot before. I use krita for artworks and it's pretty good. The animation tool is fine. If you're a beginner, use pencil 2d for a bit. Once you've been animating for a bit, I'd recommend using a "legally" acquired copy of flash. Flash 8 is good, though I've heard cs6 is also good.


hahaha I was waiting for someone to say that about flash, I will definitely consider my options in the future. Right now I guess I just wanna throw the proverbial pasta at the wall and see what sticks. Maybe if Krita doesn't work out, I'll try switching to pencil2D.


Thanks for your input :)


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-17 10:14:17


At 12/16/24 04:24 AM, DeaghlanNG wrote:Oh, one more thing. Seeing as you've used Krita and blender.

How does blender differ to Krita in terms of 2D? My understanding is you draw in more of a 3D space - I just wanted to start out with something more basic for now, then I can move on to something like that later.

Sorry for the late reply,

Blender is a 3D program, so the 2D animation as you said is correct, you are drawing in a 3D space.

Krita is a Raster based program (which means you are working with pixels) like MS Paint. Its very easy to use than Vector based art programs (vector art is to have points and have the computer do math to draw lines between those to points including curves)


The downside to Raster based programs is you are limited to the resolution you draw in, but I wouldn't worry about that.

Blender being a 3D program is a vector based program, because computers simulate 3d by drawing lines between points with 3D coordinates x,y,z. The 2d Animation in blender also fallows these rules. This allows for some different advantages, but is harder to draw (more complex). But the biggest advantage Blender has is that it is a 3D program, meaning you are able to incorporate 3D into the animation. One example would be that you can move background art Backwards and they would get smaller (like any 3d program) while still being 2D.

I personally don't find blender's 2D to be to difficult, its not that hard to animate with as you can easily do frame by frame, and rigging very easily, but all the tools fallow the same workflow as blenders 3D aspects (modifiers, color, Object selection, etc) so it can be confusing to non-Blender users, but for a Long time Blender user myself, I already understand how everything works. Though if your curious about more about how blender's 2D animation is like, watch some videos, its pretty cool, even if you don't plan on using it.

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-17 10:31:23


At 12/17/24 10:14 AM, Philosophy101YT wrote:Sorry for the late reply,


No problem at all, man. Thanks for your insight.


I've watched a few vids on blender now, I think I'll give it a proper try in future - 3D is something I might branch out into if I improve my basic skills first.


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-17 10:34:10


At 12/16/24 06:57 PM, BlakeTakesTheCake wrote:If you're a beginner, use pencil 2d for a bit.


You were totally right btw, Pencil2D seems a little more intuitive for me atm. Krita seemed a little 'laggy' dunno if I'm doing something wrong or my tablets incompatible, but Pencil2D works great.


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-17 22:42:23


At 12/17/24 10:31 AM, DeaghlanNG wrote:
At 12/17/24 10:14 AM, Philosophy101YT wrote:Sorry for the late reply,

No problem at all, man. Thanks for your insight.

I've watched a few vids on blender now, I think I'll give it a proper try in future - 3D is something I might branch out into if I improve my basic skills first.


You're Welcome!

If you ever have a question about blender, feel free to ask me.

I have enough knowledge of Blender to drive a man insane...

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-17 23:00:17


At 12/17/24 10:42 PM, Philosophy101YT wrote:You're Welcome!
If you ever have a question about blender, feel free to ask me.
I have enough knowledge of Blender to drive a man insane...


Appreciate it, man. I may just take you up on your offer, but that will take many moons at this rate LOL


BBS Signature

This might be of interest to you



EDIT: Embed didn't work apparently


I've tried to use both krita and blender to try to learn animation, I think krita had some limitations and blender had some complexities, but overall none of that mattered as I dropped trying to animate

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-18 06:53:48


At 12/18/24 03:16 AM, Scohui wrote:This might be of interest to you
I've tried to use both krita and blender to try to learn animation, I think krita had some limitations and blender had some complexities, but overall none of that mattered as I dropped trying to animate


YT searches must be busted, because I typed in almost exactly that video title and it never came up. I'll definitely give it a watch some time.


Hell, why not try animating again? Part of it seems torturous (I can't even imagine colouring in yet, just drawn some outlines), but the end result could be (hopefully) worth it :)


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-18 08:15:43


At 12/18/24 06:53 AM, DeaghlanNG wrote:
At 12/18/24 03:16 AM, Scohui wrote:This might be of interest to you
I've tried to use both krita and blender to try to learn animation, I think krita had some limitations and blender had some complexities, but overall none of that mattered as I dropped trying to animate

YT searches must be busted, because I typed in almost exactly that video title and it never came up. I'll definitely give it a watch some time.

Hell, why not try animating again? Part of it seems torturous (I can't even imagine colouring in yet, just drawn some outlines), but the end result could be (hopefully) worth it :)


Well I did drop art altogether, got a job and when you don't have a good grasp of your free time it kinda just goes all away


I've been trying to get back to at least drawing though.

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-18 08:31:39


At 12/18/24 08:15 AM, Scohui wrote:Well I did drop art altogether, got a job and when you don't have a good grasp of your free time it kinda just goes all away

I've been trying to get back to at least drawing though.


I get it - it's time consuming. I used to be a gym bunny, took it very seriously 6 days a week, then I got my first job and haven't been to the gym since LOL


Well if you do decide to do something I'll check it out!


BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-18 09:12:18


At 12/15/24 05:57 AM, DeaghlanNG wrote:Hey everyone. I appreciate this is probably a common thread, but I didn't want to go around necroposting.

I recently treated myself to a small Wacom with the intention of getting started making some dumb animations, I've had a look at the Animation Resources section of NG, as well as my own cursory searches and I think I've narrowed it down to either Krita or Pencil2D.

Is there any particular reason I should pick one or the other, or is there another program I should consider? Bear in mind I'm brand new (outside of stupid windows movie maker sprite animations I made when I was like, 10-11). I'd also heard blender could be used for 2D, but from what I understand it's really more for editing 3D environments.

Thanks in advance. <3

krita is bad. Pencil2D is hard. You can try adobe animate and toom boom harmony. But if you want a free software, you can try tahoma2D or wick editor.


You also can try adobe flash, you can download it somewhere on the internet.


Artist, animator, voice actor, editor and background artist.

BBS Signature

Response to Krita, Pencil2D or otherwise. 2024-12-18 10:44:45


At 12/18/24 09:12 AM, Simoes1000 wrote:krita is bad. Pencil2D is hard. You can try adobe animate and toom boom harmony. But if you want a free software, you can try tahoma2D or wick editor.

You also can try adobe flash, you can download it somewhere on the internet.


Yeah, I didn't really like Krita in the end - felt like it was laggy for some reason.

I actually quite like Pencil2D, it's been pretty intuitive so far imo.


I've spent a lot of money this month, which is unusual for me as I'm a 'tight-arse' as we say in Scotland. Just got my first smartphone in 7-8 years LOL gonna post some old paper drawings later with the camera. So any paid software will have to be acquired some otherr time.


BBS Signature