Well animated but the Spanish civil war was not simply 'Communists vs Fascists' this does not give a very accurate depiction of the sides in the war, also it is titled Homage to Catalonia and I do not see anything Catalan about this. You said it took a long time and I appreciate that but I think you could of stood to spend a bit more time on detail, if anyone does not know anything about the Spanish civil war they will get the complete wrong impression about this, especially as a lot of Americans like to vilainize 'commies' (due to ignorance of what communism actually is)

Quite good, got potential

+good animation
+OK graphics
+Good story
+funny

-needs explanation- intro or info button afterwards eg. why wee these people in this position- not supposed to kill each other- who were they supposed to kill. Also , what does the titile mean? If this is quoted from a book or somehting you need to say so.
-sound levels need tweeking, esp the commi coming up the hill.

-Replay button and full credits, with music would make it into a full movie.

A scene zooming in for a close-up on one of the groups would be very good. It seems ambitious, but its the next level of animation and story telling and would guarentee a higher score.

this is good material, please work on it- then do more!

why wern't the commies allowed to shoot the facist

why were they given that order?

pretty funny

at first when i saw the name i thought it was gonna be something stupid but this was one of the funnier things ive seen all day i mean how often does something effectivly bash both the commies and the facist in one blow it was even the graphics were well suiting i dont think you should change a thing on this even if you had to

A good attempt

This was not horrible, not even bad really. There was no VO, but no VO is better then horrible VO. The animation was incredible for stick art, and the flow of the text was good. A nice short story. Not the next big thing, but as I said, a good attempt.