uhhh
what he said.
Reviews for "CT: Fall of Guardia Part1"
Vinstigator responds:
What did he say?
:o
Could have been a work of art...
I'm going to have to agree with AdShap, that this is not front page material. Everyone can tell that you are a CT fan and you put time and effort into this however the quality and usage of sprites is begining to become overused.
For one the sprite movements were gritty and the backrounds were obvious emulator screen shots. The story I liked, even if it was a tad bit cliche. I'm not going to tell you how to make movies because you are supirior to me. THe problem with using sprites is you can no alternate camera angles and watching the scenes can get boring easily. I'm sorry if these words seem harsh, but overall I gave this movie a 3, its still worth watching. Just so you know I am a fan of your other works.
Vinstigator responds:
This was actually an older movie (before I made Part 13 of my "Day After series) so it may not be up to par with my current stuff. But I was going for story in this and it seemed you liked it, so that's cool.
um
ok i know we made a truce and everything, but all things aside for now, i have to say: wtf?
this is the 3rd time you've submitted this from what i've seen, and that's when i've been on the portal, then there's the fact that as far as i can tell of all the times it's been submitted there have been no real updates
i don't know what you're trying to do by posting this yet again, meh
what i really don't get though is why you choose this one to be resubmitted, personally, it's the worst one you made, and from what i see there's nothing new, i've heard that you posted a topic asking people to vote high for some reaso. Not cool, you can't use friends like that, they have the right to be honest, and some might actually like it but the rest who get told to do else wise shouldn't be voting 5's if they didn't think it was, and like that philosophy i have to do the same and vote what i feel it needs, sorry if that offends you but im a kid of honesty, not charity
oh and i know im sorta abusing the truce thing made but i had to say this, if you feel like doing the same back then go right ahead, but i would rather the peace stayed afterwards
Vinstigator responds:
Dude the other one was the OLD version! If you haven't noticed, I added a menu and bonus features! And I chose to re submit this one because I feel it's one of my most underrated movies and it has potential. And the fact that it made front page proves it. I still want the truce to stand but I must say, this review was quite pointless...
hmm..
Well to tell u the truth this isn't all that great. I thought it would be good at first when i saw it was about Chrono Trigger but in the end it didn't keep me entertained for long. The fights were ok but to short. Don't bother watching this its a waste of time.
Vinstigator responds:
Well I'm sorry you didn't like it, but I had to build up story for part 2...
what the?
Seriously, how did this get front page? First of all, I have to say that I have always been a great fan of Chrono Trigger having by far, one of the greatest story line ever for an RPG. So I just dont get why you would just trash a classic like that. Your animation was top notch (except for that wussy fireball samus troes at lucca) and I truly think your talent could be used in making perhaps a sequel to CT instead of a story that has nothing to do with the original.
Vinstigator responds:
Wait so you're saying my animation was top notch but yet you give me a 2? And what's wrong with making a spin off?